There comes a time in every writer’s journey when the story we imagined, the one we poured our blood, sweat, and sleepless nights into, meets the cold scrutiny of an editor’s eye. And in that moment, we see it for what it truly is. Not a failure, not a mess, but something unfinished, something waiting to be molded into its final shape. You can read about my novel here.

I recently had an editorial assessment done on my manuscript, and it was a revelation. A thorough, insightful look into the bones of my story, peeling back layers I had not thought to examine. And what I saw beneath was humbling. The world is there. The foundation is strong. The voice, the tone, the setting—those hold. But the depth? The stakes? The raw, beating heart of the tale itself? There is still work to be done. So, I return to the forge, hammer in hand, ready to shape this story into something sharper, richer, and more gripping than before.

The Art of Refinement: What Needs Strengthening

The hardest thing about writing isn’t finishing a book, it’s making it better. I’ve already built the world, drawn the map, and carved the characters into existence. But now comes the refinement, the work that separates a good story from a great one.

Clarifying the Stakes: A story is only as compelling as what’s at risk. The editor pointed out that while my protagonist’s journey is engaging, the true weight of what’s at stake could be clearer. The reader must feel the urgency, sense the looming danger, and understand why this quest, this moment, this battle matters. It is not enough for things to happen—they must demand to happen.

Strengthening Character Agency: A protagonist should not be swept along by the tide of fate, nor should they be a passenger in their own story. The editor noted that my main character, Autumn, reacts to the world around her rather than driving the action. That must change. A great protagonist chooses, even when the choices are impossible, even when all paths lead to ruin.

Raising the Trials, Deepening the Growth: Harder obstacles mean deeper growth, tension, and transformation. A hero is not merely tested; they are broken down and reshaped. If a journey does not demand something from them—if it does not scar them in some way—then it has not truly changed them.

Refining the Point of View: I chose an omniscient perspective, believing it would offer a grand, sweeping look at the world. But the editor pointed out a cost, a certain distance from the character’s experiences. A shift to third-person limited could make the story more intimate, drawing the reader deeper into Autumn’s thoughts, struggles, and emotional journey. And intimacy breeds investment. When readers feel a character’s pain as their own, the story leaves a mark.

Balancing Worldbuilding with Pacing: The world is rich, textured, and alive, but perhaps too much so, too soon. Some passages weigh heavily with history, slowing the momentum. The details need to be woven into the action, letting the world reveal itself organically, through character experience rather than exposition dumps. The world should unfold naturally, not be delivered in lecture form.

Overwhelming? Yes. But Here’s the Truth.

Editing a book and truly refining it is daunting. It is standing at the base of a mountain after you’ve already climbed one and realize you must climb again, but it is steeper this time. But here is what I remind myself: I already did the hardest part. I wrote a book. I built a world out of nothing. I created characters, breathed life into them, and gave them a story to tell. That is no small feat. That is everything.

This feedback is not a wrecking ball—it is a sculptor’s chisel. It does not destroy; it refines. It makes sharper what was dull, clearer what was murky, stronger what was fragile. And I do not need to fix everything all at once. Perhaps I start with deepening my character’s motivations. Then, I move to tightening the stakes. I refine, I adjust, I carve away what does not serve the story, until only the truest, strongest version of it remains.

A New Title for a New Chapter?

One last thing… the title. Titles are promises to the reader, and the editor pointed out that my current title may not best reflect the heart of the story. This tale is evolving, deepening, and becoming something richer than it was before. Perhaps the title must evolve as well. That decision is yet to be made, but I am open to it. A book, after all, is alive—changing, growing, never truly finished, only shaped until it is strong enough to stand on its own.

Final Thoughts: The Fire of Creation

Stories are not forged in a single draft. They are shaped through heat, pressure, and relentless refinement. I am not discouraged because I know that with each edit, each adjustment, each painstaking decision, I am crafting something better, deeper, and truer than before. So, I return to the forge. I take up the hammer. And I make this story worthy of the telling.

Thank you for reading.

Shaping a Stronger Story, Shaping a Stronger Story, Shaping a Stronger Story, Shaping a Stronger Story, Shaping a Stronger Story